When comparing health plans during open enrollment, people often look at the monthly premium first. While it’s an important part of the decision, it doesn’t tell you what your healthcare may actually cost over the year.
For example, imagine you’re comparing two health plans. One has a lower monthly premium but a higher deductible. The other plan costs more each month but has a lower deductible and different copays or coinsurance.
If you rarely need medical care, the lower-premium plan may be appealing. But if you regularly visit specialists, take prescription medications, or expect ongoing treatment, the higher-premium plan could potentially cost less overall.
Start by calculating the annual premium for each plan. Then consider what you might pay for regular appointments, prescriptions, and other services. Remember, meeting your deductible doesn’t necessarily mean you’re done paying. Copays and coinsurance may continue until you reach your out-of-pocket maximum.
One thing worth double-checking is the provider network. Even when the same insurance company offers two plans, their networks may differ. If keeping a particular doctor, specialist, hospital, or medical group is important to you, verify that the plan you’re considering includes them.
Prescription coverage can also make a difference. A medication covered under one plan may have different costs or coverage requirements under another. Checking your prescriptions before enrolling can help you avoid surprises.
The goal isn’t necessarily to find the plan with the lowest premium or deductible. Choose coverage that fits your healthcare needs and budget. Before making your final decision, review each plan’s Summary of Benefits and Coverage (SBC). It provides a standardized overview of covered services and cost-sharing, making plans easier to compare.


